Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Maya Lin’s Vietnam Veterans Memorial: Critical Analysis
Mary Shelley uses Victor Frankenstein’s creation as a warning towards classicism and rational thinking; something past the boundaries of societal and cultural norm. Firstly, Shelley shows this through each victim, namely Elizabeth Lavenza and Henry Clerval who both appreciate nature and its sublimity when Victor fails to do so as the novel progresses. Victor narrates this thought, as he states, “The delight of Clerval was proportionally greater than mine….,” and Clerval exclaims, “I could pass my life here…and among these mountains I should scarcely regret Switzerland and the Rhine.” (Shelley 117). Elizabeth, a romantic figure who appreciates nature and consists of feminine energy (damsel in distress category), seems to be the only one who can sooth Victor, as he states in chapter 22 on their “honeymoon” that “those were the last moments of my life during which I enjoyed the feeling of happiness (Shelley 142). He says previously, “Elizabeth alone had the power to draw me from these fits; her gentle voice would soothe me when transported by passion, and inspire me with human feelings when sunk poor.” She yields the only one who can heave Victor out of suffering the consequences of creating a new human species which clearly consists of pure rational thinking and scientific methods to execute. Secondly, not only does Victor become numb to nature – but the Creature as well. On the last page (166), the Creature describes his distant romantic feelings. “Some years ago, when the images which this world affords first opened upon me, when I felt the cheering warmth of summer, and heard the rustling of the leaves and the warbling of the birds, and these were all to me, I should have wept to die; now it is my only consolation.” Lastly, Shelley warns of this directly to the reader, when she states,
“Learn from me, if not by precepts, at least by my example, how dangerous is the acquirement of knowledge and how much happier that man is who believes his native town to be the world, than he who aspires to become greater than his nature will allow” (Shelly 31).
She calls for the reader to learn, if ethical law or a rule of action, then by the examples and tragedies that occurred. She continues to say that someone who stays in their place – and doesn’t seek to play god, is one who lives the most satisfying life, rather than someone like Victor, who goes against the forces of nature and suffers the consequences.
To highlight the impact of architectural difference and innovation in general, Maya Lin rather embraces what Shelley warns of; encouraging future thinkers to travel past the boundaries of societal and cultural norm. Even though creating a human species in the 1800s and creating a Vietnam Veteran’s Memorial in the 21st century, differ, both think uniquely outside of the box. Ever since, a kid, Lin thought differently. In “Maya Lin and The Great Call Of China” she explains growing up. “I used to birdwatch when I was young. There’s not much else to do in Athens, Ohio. It’s a perfect place to grow up…totally safe. You can leave your keys in your car, leave your door unlocked. There’s plenty of room.” But she never fit in.
“Everyone was worried about getting As and Bs and Cs. I really thought it was silly, kind of stupid . . .All the boys and girls were interested in one another, all taking themselves so seriously.
The girls were very into makeup . . . It was just not at all my idea of life, of anything interesting.” Author Phil Mccombs says her individualism expressed itself in her clothes, and it still does, as she went around Washington in “a pink-and-white dress, purple bush jacket and gray felt porkpie hat with a black band.” He continues: Athens never felt like home. ‘My parents don’t consider Athens [and] I grew up with their feelings. I don’t feel like I have a home . . . As a result, I drift . . . Yale was the first place I felt comfortable.” Due to Lin’s success, she can be viewed as a role model, and with this image, she chooses to promote individuality, expression, and passion for her path, even if the Vietnam Veteran’s Memorial may have been deemed “disruptive innovation” initially, as it proves of something much more.
In conclusion, Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Maya Lin’s Vietnam Veterans Memorial redefine standards for travelling past societal and cultural norms as well as the impact level of divergent innovation with positive intent on negative outcome, and vice versa. To stress rightful means, both in the professional and ethical sense of intent versus outcome, Shelley employs use of narrative remorse and responsibility which makes incapable to assign blame on one particular side. Lin uses the element of continuity through her piece to suggest that positive intent does eventually outweigh a negative outcome, but also, that there may never be a fixed outcome as it shifts with social standards rather than the piece itself. While evaluating the impact of architectural difference and innovation in general, Shelley warns future designers of travelling past boundaries such as rational and classical thinking, and Lin encourages future thinkers to rather embrace difference and travelling past those boundaries of societal and cultural norm.
Corresponding to Victor’s initial situation with his creation, Lin faces an outcome of negative criticism and controversy to her virtuous intent. In 1979, Congress grants the committee of Vietnam War veterans the right to build a memorial in Washington D.C., dedicated to American soldiers killed in the Vietnam conflict. A design is put out by the committee convening a blue-ribbon panel of sculptors, architects, and landscape architects to evaluate more than 1,400 submissions. And when the winner is declared, no...
Architecture is constantly associated with its functional purpose, physical appearance and its amenity. However, maintains a much more inadvertent role which surpasses far beyond the physical and material world in which we live and enters the intangible realm of our existential memory. ’A mental meditation between the world and our consciousness’ . Successful architecture is displayed in the completeness, credibility and the unquestioned prestige of experience. Memory is involved indisputably throughout this, between the space and experiencing person lies an...
The interrelationship between modern architecture and utopian design is ever present in the architecture we are surrounded by in society today. Yet behind the facades of these buildings, lies a great deal more purpose and meaning that defines this 20th century revolution. This radical movement in architecture saw traditional design and ways of thinking completely re-evaluated within their context in society. Coleman’s thesis explores the relationship of these vital movements in architecture, while investigating a dissimilarity between projects of a...
William Golding uses different types of symbolism throughout the story “Lord of the flies”. The first symbol of ‘the beast’ will be explained in depth and talked about how it effects the characters within the story. Paragraph 2 includes piggy’s glasses, which are very symbolic for a simple thing and also creates a signal fire. Paragraph 3 is about the fire which is used a lot throughout the story, having strong meanings and symbols towards it, as well as helping...
In this written piece I will be investigating how typography is used to brand films. Films more often than not use word marks for branding purposes rather than using iconography; as the word-mark spells out the name of the film and is often stylized towards the specific genre or direction of the film. Due to the heavy saturation of word-marks used in the branding of films can this element alone alter the image of a film before a minute of...
When an object is perceived as ‘beautiful’ by an individual, to use as an example, “This rose is beautiful” then that statement must then have a predetermined judgement on something that is universally ‘agreeable’. This reasoning that the rose must be beautiful is, as Kant would describe it, an individual’s subjective feeling towards the rose and as stated before must in turn be universally validified. Our aesthetic judgments interact with the world around us in the way that beauty is...
Introduction The Modernism movement began in the 20th Century. It is seen as being a more logical approach to the purpose of the building as well as using new materials (History.com, 2019) ,(UKEssays.com, 2019). I aim, to investigate into the Architectural response of the Great Depression. As well as comparing what Architecture was like prior to The Great Depressions and the Architectural response because of it. As well as understanding how such large skyscrapers such as the Empire State and...
Introduction The Modernism movement started within the Twentieth Century. It is seen as being a more logical approach to the purpose of the building as well as utilizing new materials (History.com, 2019). Architect Louis Sullivan view was that “form follows function”, which means designing a building that has the essentials needs (Wiki, 2019) This essay aims to investigate what Skyscrapers resembled during the ’20s-’30s compared to now and seeing if the Modernist style has advanced throughout the years. As well...
Aristotle was a philosopher who wrote many works about ethics, politics, metaphysics, and aesthetics. His conception of beauty was classical, indeed he saw beauty as “an arrangement of integral parts into a coherent whole, according to proportion, harmony, symmetry (…)” (Sartwell, 2016). The main idea of his concept is that beauty is a sort of middle between excess and deficiency; indeed, beauty is not the concept of sublime neither is the concept of ugliness, it is in the arrangement between...
01 / 09
Fair Use Policy
EduBirdie considers academic integrity to be the essential part of the learning process and does not support any violation of the academic standards. Should you have any questions regarding our Fair Use Policy or become aware of any violations, please do not hesitate to contact us via firstname.lastname@example.org.
We are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours.