Order of Cumulative Adjectives
1. Adjectives used attributively (i.e. used before nouns) can be either cumulative
or coordinate. Unlike coordinate adjectives, cumulative adjectives are from
different semantic categories, have to be used in certain order, and cannot be
joined by and or be separated by commas—for example, I have a small old
blue Japanese car. Although more than three adjectives rarely occur in speech
or writing, as many as seven cumulative adjectives can come before a noun:
det. opinion
size
shape
condition
age
color
origin
noun
an
big
round
chipped
old
blue
French
table
ugly
2. However, not every native speaker agrees with the above order. The table
below shows the correlations between the above predicted order and the order
given by 30 native speakers of English:
opinion
size
shape
condition
age
color
origin
.80
.96
.66
.79
.85
.77
1.0
noun
These results indicate that while the established order is valid, it is not equally
fixed for all types of adjectives.
3. As we saw in the example from the cartoon in the Newsweek magazine,
coordinate adjectives are from the same semantic category—thus, their order is
not fixed—and are usually separated by the comma, although using and instead
of the comma is also possible, e.g. Clinton was a charming, attractive (or an
attractive, charming) President.
4. Some coordinate adjectives, however, have to be conjoined with and, as in an
orange and white marble and a black and white TV. With these adjectives,
using only one of them would be semantically misleading.