Discipline with Dignity:
Curwin and Mendler
Theorists Richard L. Curwin and Allen N. Mendler are the founders of the classroom
management plan entitled Discipline with Dignity. This management plan entails many
important points but essentially establishes a social contract between the teacher and class. They
take insight from theorist Glasser, of not destroying children’s will to learn through discipline.
Not only is a contract decided by teacher and students but the consequences to discipline
problems are made together as well. Three points are essential to this plan including: prevention,
action dimension, and resolution. This theory is not a quick fix but rather focuses on long-term
behavior changes.
Some ideas I find appealing in this discipline theory are the theories in which it is based
on. Teachers must never embarrass students when carrying out the consequences of the contract.
This is supposed to be done in private and this way the child does not feel defeated by the
mocking of his/her peers. Another aspect that I appreciate in Curwin and Mendler’s plan is that
prevention is a main agent in the management plan. By preventing problems, the teacher will
spend less time implementing consequences and more time teaching. Preplanning is thinking
about the activities the class will be doing and thinking ways in which students will have
difficulty and trying to eliminate them. My personal philosophy has a lot to do with respecting
the children and one of my personal goals is not to embarrass them as I do not like to be
embarrassed myself. Another component of my personal management plan comes from Harry
Wong. Mendler and Curwin’s ideas remind me of Wong’s because he is ad emit about
preventing problems by having set procedures. I am drawn to this theory because of the
similarity. One aspect Curwin and Mendler’s plan that I don’t quite agree with is the fact that
student’s are able to choose their own consequence. I do not feel that this is appropriate because
at time students do not know what is best for them. As an experienced and studied adult I feel
that I have the ability to make a decision such as this for the student. However, I am not opposed
to suggestions from the student; I feel as the teacher I have the ultimate decision.
After reviewing several studies of the model, I believe that it is a practical theory to be
used in the classroom. It is not too difficult to understand and it has good basic concepts.
Prevention is always key in my mind and this method definitely takes hold of that concept. I
also feel that the students will enjoy being part of the discipline control process and will strive to
be better students because they had a say in the process. As a teacher, using this model will
bring much success because it requiers the teacher to be consistent, kind and well-practiced.