Reddy – The Conduit Metaphor
The figurative assertion that communication works by embedding thoughts and feelings in
speech and physically transferring them from speaker to hearer.
Get thoughts across, idea of what you’re thinking, hollow words, impenetrable remarks
Saussure – person sending stuff over to other person’s head, and it continues
The speech circuit = an audition and phonation cycle
Toolmaker’s Paradigm
Only receive instructions, use own interpretation and decode
Like English – gaining meaning as wholes, forgetting interpretative work to understand
Hearer/Listener orientation
Opacity of other minds – believe other minds are inaccessible = interpreting their thoughts
Lies – begins when young, later starts to suspect lies (questions about what is true)
Changing expressions and complexity of words to obscure mind into listening more / leaning in
Writing as a model for what speech is
Some ways of speaking are better than others
Monolingualism is norma/natural
Communication = packing thoughts into words and sending them over to hearers to unwrap
Enfield SEMISIS – meaning making
Chain if signifying actions , incorporates saurssan, indexical, icon
A – agent (person who is actively doing something)
S – sign (actions, words, expressions, tone of voice that is perceptible)
O-Object that the sign is referring to
I – interpreat, whatever meaning as next sign (take something as something else) Ex. Two people eating
A1 S1 – the chicken is bland
S2 – grab salt (revelvance) or ask if want salt, etc.
I1 – thank you
Ex.
S1- hears someone say how was the movie
S2 – thumbs up or it was good
I1 – what made it good, or questioning the relevance if it was good
“Conventional machine” - builds on humans’ special attunement to what others think,
feel, mean, are trying to do
Cognition for language is intrinsically dialogic = ongoing cycle of communication
Conversation calls upon participants to make a moral commitment = interactions in
listening to speakers (ex. Teachers) connects emotions to it
Language use is a cooperative activity = being in a “with”
Ex. Walking together with a person as a with. Randomly speeding up = immoral
● Turn-taking in work
● Project/anticipate at multiple scales “preliminary work” in place formulation
● Correct to maintain the with or excuse to withdraw from it