The concept of respect, particularly how it is earned, given, or withheld, forms a fundamental aspect of human interaction and social dynamics in literature. Through careful examination of Raymond Carver's "Cathedral" and Alice Walker's "Everyday Use," we discover how respect manifests through character interactions and evolves as perspectives shift. These stories, though distinct in their settings and contexts, share compelling parallels in their exploration of how characters learn to respect others by overcoming their initial prejudices and preconceptions. The transformation of respect in these narratives offers profound insights into the human capacity for growth and understanding.
Initial Perceptions
In both narratives, the protagonists begin with deeply flawed perspectives that prevent them from truly respecting others. Carver's narrator in "Cathedral" exhibits obvious prejudice toward blind people, viewing Robert, his wife's blind friend, through a lens of stereotypes and misconceptions. "My idea of blindness came from the movies," the narrator admits, revealing how his understanding is shaped by superficial, media-driven representations rather than genuine knowledge or experience. His dismissive attitude extends beyond mere ignorance; it reveals a deeper inability to connect with experiences different from his own.
Save your time!
We can take care of your essay
- Proper editing and formatting
- Free revision, title page, and bibliography
- Flexible prices and money-back guarantee
Similarly, in "Everyday Use," Dee's initial attitude toward her family heritage demonstrates a form of disrespect cloaked in intellectual superiority. She returns home with a changed name and a patronizing attitude, viewing her mother and sister Maggie as somehow lesser for maintaining their traditional way of life. Her education has created a barrier between her and her family's authentic cultural experience, leading to a form of cultural tourism rather than genuine respect. The story poignantly illustrates how academic knowledge without emotional connection can result in a superficial understanding that masquerades as respect.
Transformative Moments
The transformation of respect in these stories occurs through powerful moments of revelation and connection. In "Cathedral," the pivotal scene where Robert guides the narrator's hand in drawing a cathedral becomes a metaphor for breaking down barriers of understanding. The physical act of drawing together creates an intimate connection that transcends the narrator's prejudices. As he closes his eyes and continues drawing, he experiences an epiphany: "It was like nothing else in my life up to now." This moment represents more than just learning about blindness; it embodies the development of genuine respect through shared experience.
Walker's story presents its transformative moment through the conflict over family quilts. When Mama chooses to give the quilts to Maggie rather than Dee, she demonstrates respect for authentic connection to heritage over intellectual appreciation. The quilts, hand-stitched by generations of family members, represent a living tradition that Maggie will continue to use and honor in daily life. This decision forces readers to consider what true respect for cultural heritage means – whether it's better preserved behind glass or lived through daily use and appreciation. The moment challenges conventional notions about preservation and respect, suggesting that true respect often involves active engagement rather than passive reverence.
Cultural Dimensions
Both stories explore how cultural understanding influences respect. In "Cathedral," the narrator's transformation involves overcoming not just prejudice against blindness, but also his own cultural isolation. His wife's connection with Robert through years of exchanged tapes represents a depth of communication and respect that initially eludes him. The story suggests that respect often requires stepping outside one's cultural comfort zone and engaging with different perspectives and experiences. The narrator's journey from isolation to connection mirrors broader societal struggles with difference and diversity.
Walker's narrative delves deeper into cultural respect through the lens of African American heritage. Dee's academic understanding of her culture, symbolized by her changed name to "Wangero," represents a form of respect that paradoxically distances her from authentic cultural connection. As literary scholar Maria Johnson notes, "Walker presents a complex meditation on what it means to truly honor one's heritage versus simply appropriating its symbols." The contrast between Dee's intellectual appreciation and Maggie's lived experience raises important questions about authentic cultural respect.
Moving Beyond Prejudice
The process of overcoming prejudice to achieve genuine respect forms a central theme in both works. Carver's narrator must confront his own biases about disability, moving from superficial tolerance to genuine connection. His initial attempts at politeness mask a deeper discomfort and lack of respect, but through direct experience and vulnerability, he achieves a more authentic understanding. The story suggests that true respect often requires personal transformation and the willingness to acknowledge one's own limitations. This journey from prejudice to understanding is not merely personal; it reflects broader societal struggles with acceptance and inclusion.
In "Everyday Use," the transformation operates on multiple levels. Mama's character demonstrates the importance of respecting authentic connections to heritage, even when they don't align with modern academic interpretations. Her decision to give the quilts to Maggie represents a form of respect that values lived experience over intellectual understanding. As scholar Thomas Peterson argues, "Walker's story challenges readers to consider how respect for tradition can coexist with progress without diminishing either." The narrative suggests that genuine respect for cultural heritage requires a delicate balance between preservation and living tradition.
Implications and Impact
The evolution of respect in these stories carries broader implications for contemporary society. Both narratives demonstrate how personal transformation can lead to deeper understanding and genuine respect for others. The characters' journeys suggest that respect is not a static concept but a dynamic process that requires active engagement and willingness to change. These stories challenge readers to examine their own biases and consider how their respect for others might be limited by preconceptions or superficial understanding.
Conclusion
Through their distinct but complementary explorations of respect, these stories reveal how genuine respect often requires personal transformation and the abandonment of preconceived notions. Both narratives demonstrate that respect isn't simply about polite behavior or intellectual appreciation, but about genuine connection and understanding. The characters' journeys from prejudice to understanding mirror broader societal struggles with difference and appreciation of diverse perspectives. As readers, we are challenged to examine our own assumptions and consider how our respect for others might be limited by our preconceptions and biases. These stories ultimately suggest that true respect emerges not from distant appreciation or theoretical understanding, but from genuine engagement with others' experiences and perspectives. In doing so, they provide valuable insights into the nature of respect and its role in human relationships and cultural understanding.
Stuck on your essay?
