I. Introduction
The New Deal, implemented by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Great Depression, remains one of the most significant and debated economic programs in American history. While it aimed to alleviate the hardships of the Depression and restore economic stability, it encountered various challenges and criticisms. This essay explores the failures of the New Deal, examining different perspectives on its effectiveness and impact.
II. Barton Bernstein's View: Protecting Capitalism
Barton Bernstein offers a perspective that the New Deal primarily aimed to protect American corporate capitalism rather than challenge it. Bernstein critiques Roosevelt's conservative approach, arguing that it failed to address the root causes of economic inequality and the power of big businesses. Moreover, Bernstein highlights the exclusion of marginalized groups, such as African Americans, from the benefits of New Deal programs, perpetuating racial inequalities.
Save your time!
We can take care of your essay
- Proper editing and formatting
- Free revision, title page, and bibliography
- Flexible prices and money-back guarantee
III. Robert Higgs's Critique: Prolonging the Depression
Robert Higgs presents a critical view of the New Deal, suggesting that it may have actually prolonged the Great Depression. Higgs argues that Roosevelt's expansion of government power and intervention in the economy interfered with free-market principles, leading to increased uncertainty and hindering economic recovery. Furthermore, Higgs expresses concerns about the erosion of individual liberties and the long-term impact on economic productivity due to excessive government intervention.
IV. David Kennedy's Advocacy: Upholding American Principles
David Kennedy offers a more favorable view of the New Deal, emphasizing its transformative impact on American society. He highlights Roosevelt's vision of inclusivity and social security, which aimed to provide relief to those most affected by the Depression. Kennedy acknowledges the shortcomings of the New Deal but emphasizes its positive legacies, such as the establishment of social security programs and government regulations to prevent future economic crises.
V. Comparison and Contrast of Perspectives
While Bernstein, Higgs, and Kennedy offer different perspectives on the failures of the New Deal, there are common themes and divergent viewpoints among them. Bernstein and Higgs criticize the New Deal for its failure to address systemic inequalities and its potential negative impact on economic recovery. In contrast, Kennedy emphasizes the positive legacies of the New Deal and its role in upholding American principles of inclusivity and social security.
VI. Conclusion
In conclusion, the failures of the New Deal are subject to debate and interpretation. While some historians criticize its conservative approach and unintended consequences, others emphasize its transformative impact on American society. Regardless of differing perspectives, the New Deal remains a crucial chapter in American history, offering valuable lessons for addressing economic challenges and ensuring social welfare in the future.
Stuck on your essay?
