It all started when a replica of a mummy came to haunt and in the process was destroying a bed and breakfast in Pleasantview. Who could it be? George Broderick is one of the suspects, and he is the mummy imposter. George Broderick has the best motive and opportunity, unlike Chester Gibbons.
George Broderick's motive is money. A letter that George wrote to Agatha asking “ Will you marry me and make me the happiest, the richest man in the world?” This is showing us that he cares about money. (Ashmolean Museum Oxford letter) He thinks Raymond Peabody hid the treasure in the Peabody house, and this is why he is haunting the house. He is trying to ruin the bed and breakfast so that he will be able to buy the Peabody house so that he can find the cat. This cat, that Raymond Peabody hid in the house came from Rakutamen’s tomb, and the Olde Curiosity Shop offered him a great deal for it. (Olde Curiosity Shop letter) George was on the archaeology trip with Raymond. (Professor Peabody and The Curse Of The Mummy) He accused Raymond of stealing the cat. (Agatha's diary entry)This is why he knows about the cat. Next, he can sell the cat and collect all the money. He is in addition the only one who has seen the mummy. (Letter to the Editor)This is saying that he is the only one to have examined the mummy. He could have made the thing up to make the bed and breakfast fail.
George Broderick has the best opportunity. He lives right next door so nobody would be suspicious if he were to be walking past the Peabody house. (Letter to the editor). That would mean nobody would think twice that he is perpetrating a crime if he walks by.
Chester Gibbons may look suspicious, but George has a worthier motive and opportunity. It may have looked suspicious when Chester was in the house late at night, but right after he left the mummy approached into the house. If it were George, he could have seen that he left. Then went to try to find the cat. Then had to have a disguise there for nobody would turn him in. He also doesn't want anybody too skeptical of him.
George Broderick has the best motive and opportunity. He desires all the money when he finds that cat. He has the best opportunity because he lives right next door. He is guilty.
Cite this paper
Argumentative Essay on George Broderick and a Cat.
(2023, July 11). Edubirdie. Retrieved May 5, 2024, from https://edubirdie.com/examples/argumentative-essay-on-george-broderick-and-a-cat/
“Argumentative Essay on George Broderick and a Cat.” Edubirdie, 11 Jul. 2023, edubirdie.com/examples/argumentative-essay-on-george-broderick-and-a-cat/
Argumentative Essay on George Broderick and a Cat. [online].
Available at: <https://edubirdie.com/examples/argumentative-essay-on-george-broderick-and-a-cat/> [Accessed 5 May 2024].
Argumentative Essay on George Broderick and a Cat [Internet]. Edubirdie.
2023 Jul 11 [cited 2024 May 5].
Available from: https://edubirdie.com/examples/argumentative-essay-on-george-broderick-and-a-cat/
copy
Stuck on your essay?
