Standardized Testing As a Flawed Concept: Critical Analysis of Disadvantages
Exams often do little more than measure a person’s ability to take exams.
A test or examination is an assignment intended to measure a test-takes knowledge, skill, aptitude, physical fitness or classification in many other subjects.
Imagine if failing a test was considered to be a failure for your whole life.
Even though standardized tests can help schools evaluate progress. However, scores do not provide a true picture of a student ability. So therefore it should be outlawed.
Standardized tests are special examinations designed to measure students ’ intellectual competency or academic potential. These tests, which feature strict uniformity concerning content, administration, and scoring, have become a key part of the American education system since they were first introduced in the nineteenth century. Some of the most well-known and widely taken standardized tests include college entrance exams such as the SAT and ACT and licensing exams like the United States Medical Licensing Examination. In addition to offering information on individual students’ abilities, standardized tests provide valuable insight on the overall academic performance of entire student bodies. Such information is frequently used to ensure accountability among schools and teachers . Standardized testing is a controversial subject, however, with critics typically arguing that such testing is too often misleading, ineffective, and even biased. ‘Standardized Testing.’ Gale Student Resources in Context, Gale, 2017. Student Resources In Context.
Standardized testing fails to yield any valuable information about students’ long-term academic growth. Worse yet, pressure to perform well on standardized tests puts an incredible amount of stress on students and teachers alike that only serves to inhibit learning ‘Standardized Testing.’ Gale Student Resources in Context, Gale, 2017. Student Resources In Context. This shows that standardized testing are ineffective when testing a person’s intelligence because, if you’re taking a test under so much stress and pressure, how is that an effective way to determine how smart you are ? When people are under pressure they do not perform really well, this is scientifically approved. Some kids do well with a certain level of stress. Other students fold. Brain research suggests that too much stress is psychologically and physically harmful. And when stress becomes overwhelming, the brain shifts into a fight or flight response, where it is impossible to engage in the higher-order thinking processes that are necessary to respond correctly to the standardized test questions. So standardized testing is obviously not the way and therefore it should be banned.
Even though standardized tests also tend to be more objective than tests that teachers create and administer directly to their own students. But it fails to yield any valuable information about students’ long-term academic growth. So a test that tend to be more objective that teachers tests also has no impact on a student’s academic “Callahan, R. (1962). Education and the cult of efficiency: A study of the social forces that have shaped the administration of the public schools. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press”. This is definitely not the best way of testing a student’s ability because you wouldn’t know if it’s effective if it doesn’t have any impact on the students and therefore should be outlawed.
Standardized tests (SAT) are ”incredibly imprecise” when it comes to measuring academic ability and how well students will perform in college “Study of Standardized Admissions Tests Is Big Draw at College Conference. The New York Times. (Sept. 29, 2008) Lexile Measure: 1460L. COPYRIGHT 2008 The New York Times Company”.
It is not worth it. The SAT teaches children a narrow range of test taking skills, not ones that will prepare them for selective colleges, entrepreneurship or active citizenship. The SAT teaches kids to view reading as a meaningless assignment rather than a source of ideas or inspiration.Tampio, Nicholas. ‘Commentary: Time to Ditch the SAT.’ The Report, from U.S. News & World Report, 13 Apr. 2018. Student Resources In Context. Well what is the point of the SAT, is it fair to let a test determine whether or not if you should get into college or not, or whether if you’re smart or not ? This just doesn’t make sense and standardized testing needs to be banned.
Standardized achievement tests are deeply flawed, and test-based accountability has been terribly damaging to public education. “The paradox of standardized testing Phi Delta Kappan. (Nov. 2017) Lexile Measure: 1360L. COPYRIGHT 2017 Phi Delta Kappa.”
This is outrageous because some students know that their test scores may affect their future lives so they do whatever they can just to pass them, including cheating and taking performance drugs. It shouldn’t have to be like this there are many other ways, standardized testing is not an option so therefore it should be outlawed.
Standardized testing have negative impacts on students mentally by bringing their moral down which could possibly leads to worst. Standardized testing creates winners and losers. The losers are those who get labeled as “ low students, learning disabled kids, reluctant learners.” Even the winners are trapped by being caught up on a treadmill of achievement that they must stay on at all costs through at least sixteen years of schooling, and more often twenty years. The losers suffer loss of self-esteem, and the damage of “low expectations”. The Myth of the ADHD Child: 101 Ways to Improve Your Child’s Behavior and Attention Span Without Drugs, Labels, or Coercion (Tarcher-Perigee). Students are already going through so much stress during senior year, more specifically getting into college. So they should not be challenged again that with Standardized test to determine if they’re going to college or not or to lower their self esteem if they have a bad score so Therefore the standardized testing most definitely be banned.
Throughout the text, there was more than enough evidence to prove that standardized testing does not provide a true picture of a student ability and should be outlawed. We went over many effects and disadvantages such as failing to yield any valuable information about students’ long-term academic growth, negative impacts on students mentally by bringing their moral.
So now do you want to do things a different way, try a new method or do you want to keep abusing the future of this country by stressing them out and lowering their self esteem?
Commercialization of Education in Standardized Testing The commercialization of education is defined as private ownership of educational institutions that make investments for the motive of earning profit. Recently, the commercialization of education has proliferated on a global scale because of the reliance of standardized testing for acceptance into higher educational institutions. Marketing tactics used by corporate entities have shifted the priority of society from viewing students as learners to consumers of education who have monetary value. Standardized testing is one...
How do you feel when there will be a test coming up in school? What if it’s a really important test, like a midterm or final test of the school year? I mean you definitely have to spend the time to review and memorize it, right? But have you ever wondered if the standardized test actually measures ability? Most students know that standardized tests have been a major part for them in the United States due to the reason that...
This all started from the beginning of the 19th Century when the United States began taking in immigrants fleeing from Europe due to the devastation of World War I. During this time Carl C. Brigham—a professor of psychology at Princeton University— published A Study of American Intelligence (1923) “in which he emphasized that the decline in America’s intelligence was attributable to the influx of low IQ immigrants” (Strout and Stuart, 133). Brigham came to this conclusion by creating puzzles for...
I woke up one friday and noticed that the SAT was the next day. I crammed a bunch of information into my head with the fear that if I managed to fail the test, it would be impossible for me to ever get into a college, but as I was studying all these different types of subjects that I haven’t reviewed for years, I asked myself if this simple test taken by majority of Americans is really a good indicator...
With the evolution of mankind and the constant advancement in technology, there should be a match in education system. What I mean by this is that the No Child Left Behind Act of 2002 has caused the regression of intelligence and stagnation of education in the United States. This is identified in a multitude of ways by philosophers throughout the ages, great scientific minds of their time, and even the great minds of today that shape the future that is...
When it comes to any assessment, there will always be a negative and a positive side to it. Most of the time one usually outweighs the other, especially when it is an assessment that isn’t entirely fair to a certain group of people. In regards to standardized testing, many negative risks and consequences arise from the use of it as a way of accessing someone’s individual grade level and retention of information because of the disadvantages it creates. Not every...
Elimination of Standardized Testing Before standardized testing, the only way to measure students’ growth and knowledge was through oral testing. In 1915, Frederick J. Kelly published a book containing the first standardized test as well as its instructions for anyone administering the test. Now standardized tests are given to students usually starting in kinder, or even pre-kinder, all the way through the rest of their education. Initially, the goal of standardized testing was an alternative to oral testing for determining...
Michelle Obama, most would describe her as a very successful and intelligent individual with all of her accomplishments including graduating from Princeton University as Cum Laude with a bachelor’s degree in Sociology and continuing her education at Harvard University law school. Mrs. Obama once stated “if my future were determined just by my performance on a standardized test, I wouldn’t be here. I can guarantee that”. Mrs. Obama, one of the most influential and intelligent women in the world, did...
As early as 2001, with the implementation of accountability policies such as No Child Left Behind (NCLB), and Race to the Top (RttT), there has been an increased emphasis on students standardized test scores. These policies use student’s performance on such tests as a means of funding schools, such that higher scoring schools receive more funds, and lower scoring schools receive less funds. Teachers are now being held accountable for students test scores (Valli and Buese), with negative consequences affecting...
01 / 09
Fair Use Policy
EduBirdie considers academic integrity to be the essential part of the learning process and does not support any violation of the academic standards. Should you have any questions regarding our Fair Use Policy or become aware of any violations, please do not hesitate to contact us via email@example.com.
We are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours.