The Issue Of Nationalism In All Quiet On The Western Front
The historical-fiction novel All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque describes the atrocities of World War I from the perspective of the Germans. The war started in 1914 and lasted till 1918, nationalism being a large contributor towards the starting of this war. Across these 4 years there was a casualty count of over 40 million. The slaughter and destruction was so great that it was branded as “the war to end all wars.” In 1917, The author was drafted into this atrocious war at the age of 18. With the experience he gained, he sought to highlight the atrocities of the war, many of which are seemingly compiled into this novel. Through the eyes of Paul Bäumer, the audience witnesses much of the author’s personal experiences. This includes the horrible conditions of the trenches, the extreme lack of food, and the mass amounts of casualties. However, on a deeper level, the author is commenting on the issue of nationalism in society. This is shown through the use of literary devices such as irony, imagery, and dialogue.
Among other literary devices, irony best demonstrates the issue of nationalism. This is first shown when Paul recalls his past as a student, “… He used to glare at us through his spectacles and say in a moving voice: ‘Won’t you join up, Comrades’ … Strange to say, Behm was one of the first to fall” (Remarque 11, 12). This quote displays Kantorek as he attempts to influence his students into joining the war effort. This proves ironic because as the scene unfolds, the audience learns that Joseph Behm, the only unwilling student in which Kantorek recruited, is one of the first of the second company to die, what brings Behm into the war is the reason for his death. Despite Behm being quite hesitant to join the war effort, he is pressured into believing that it is almost traitorous to his country to not join the war effort. “But he did allow himself to be persuaded, otherwise he would have been ostracized” (11). This demonstrates the issue of nationalism, as it is being used here as a tool to recruit much of the populace towards the awful cause that is the war, and in Behm’s case, force those who are unwilling to join.
Because of the deaths of their classmates, Paul and his friends learn to distrust Kantorek and nationalists alike. This is shown when the author states, “Yes, that’s the way they think, these hundred thousand Kantoreks! Iron Youth! Youth! We are none of us more than twenty years old. But young? Youth? That is long ago. We are old folk” (18). This depicts the scene in which the group of young men humor the letter Kantorek has sent referring to his students as the iron youth. Paul displays his hatred towards Kantorek as he brands all nationalists as Kantorek, the one that had prodded them into joining the war effort. In addition, the quote shows the hardships that has been brought upon Paul due to the war, in which they were tricked into joining, believing that it would demonstrate their nationalism, as he laughs at being called young believing that he has experienced enough to be considered an old man. But, Irony is not the only literary device used to display the problem of nationalism.
Imagery also helps to display the issue of nationalism. This is first seen when the author writes, “We were still crammed full of vague ideas which gave to life, and to the war also an ideal and almost romantic character… We recognized that what matters is not the mind but the boot brush, not intelligence but the system, not freedom but drill” (21, 22). This scene depicts Paul recalling his past life and how naive he once was. What is stated here by the author helps to instill the image in the audience’s head that everything Paul previously knew is now seemingly insignificant. In addition, it seems as if this scene teaches Paul and his friends to believe that true patriotism comes in the form of blind submission as he is forced to relinquish his freedom. This displays how nationalism is exploitable as Paul and the other students at the academy naively joined the war effort, only on the premise that it would display their patriotism, without considering the possible atrocities of the war. Because of this false premise, Paul and the rest of the students at the academy are lured into the war and are now forced to suffer the consequences as they experience their previous way of life be ripped away.
Once more, imagery is used to display the issue of nationalism. Imagery is used during the scene with the Russian prisoners when the author states, “They have faces that make one think–honest peasant faces… They look just as kindly as our own peasants in Friesland” (190). This scene depicts Paul humanizing the enemy Russian prisoners, comparing them to German peasants. The imagery present in this scene helps to depict the enemy Russians as no different from any German displaying Paul’s lack of nationalism as he begins to grow increasingly tired of the war. The author seems to be stating, through Paul humanizing the enemy Russian prisoners, that nationalism is harmful as it has brainwashed many into viewing the enemy as sub-human. The author then goes on to state, “A word of command has made these silent figures our enemies; a word of command might transform them into our friends” (193, 194). This demonstrates the lie that is nationalism, as many have been brainwashed into thinking that it is an expression of one’s pride for their country to mercilessly kill the enemy. However, this quote goes to show that the war is just unnecessary sacrifice as this dispute could simply be resolved through an agreement.
Through dialogue, the audience is able to learn how nationalism is exploitable. This becomes apparent when the author writes, “… ‘we are here to protect our fatherland. And the French are over there to protect their fatherland. Now who’s in the right’” (203). During this scene, Paul and his friends discuss which country is truly in the right. However, Paul states that maybe both countries are right, possibly both are wrong. Thus, displaying the conflicting ideology that is nationalism as everyone is led to believe that they hold the correct stance in the war. “… ‘our professors and parson and newspapers say that we are the only ones that are right… but the French professors and parsons and newspapers say that the right is on their side” (203, 204). This leads the group of young men to turn their heads toward the political powers behind the war as they begin to realize that the war is ploy for the people in power’s own personal gain, “… every full grown emperor requires at least one war, otherwise he would not become famous… We didn’t want the war… and yet half the world is in it all the same” (206). This displays the idiocy of nationalism as it assumes that a country and its people are a single entity, it requires that the citizen place the interests of the country over their own or another country.
It seems that the author is commenting of the issue of nationalism in a society. This is shown through irony through the manipulation of Behm, imagery through the loss of rights and humanizing of the enemy, and through dialogue as Paul and his friends reason that political leaders play off of nationalistic ideals for their own personal gain. Through the commenting on the issue of nationalism, it appears that the author reveals to the audience, parts of the nature of our species. He seems to believe that as a whole, the human race is oblivious, blindly following a leader without question. Through the exposing of this human flaw, the author attempts to reform, attempting to rid of this blind submission.
Archaeology is the study of the artifacts and remains of humans from all around the world. This study is carried out by methods including surveying sites, excavations and classifying of artifacts found. Through these methods, a sense of cultural identity can be found. However, Colonialism in Africa and Nationalism in the Middle East obscure the true cultural identity of the native inhabitants of countries such as Zimbabwe and Israel. This essay will define colonialism in relation to the example of...
A fundemental question that is asked is ‘what defines national identity’? Is it the way people speak? The way they move? Or is it what makes the country stand out? The Oxford Dictionary defines nationalsim as ‘Identification with one’s own nation and support for its interests, especially to the exclusion or detriment of the interests of other nations.'(Dcitionary, 2018) Taking this into consideration it is important to look into how nationalsim is portrayed throughout various types of performance. This essay...
Webster’s dictionary defines nationalism as loyalty and dedication to a nation, especially in the sense of a national consciousness that promotes a country above other countries and emphasizes the promotion of its culture and interests. Not the culture and interests of other countries or supranational regions. In simple terms, nationalism can be described as a kind of love and pride for one’s own country, and the belief that one’s own country is better than any other country. But it means...
For nationalism to prosper, clearly the United States needed to demonstrate its test effectively. The War of 1812 was one demonstrating ground. More noteworthy than a strategic accomplishment against Britain was the marvelous ascent in the national economy, started by populace increment, regional acquisitions, and mechanical changes in transportation and industry. The unfaltering aggregation of influence to the focal government to the detriment of the states was likened to the development of America. Nationalism suggested the denigration of sectionalism and...
Introduction Rabindranath Tagore would have never imagined that his composition would have become such a debatable issue. The contention behind Bharato Bhagyo Bidhata was to bring countrymen under one flag by putting aside their differences. The first stanza of Bharato Bhagyo Bidhatha is the national anthem of India. It has become the sixty-four thousand dollar question after the SC passed the order that it would be compulsory to stand in cinema halls for National Anthem as a gesture of respect....
South Africa, a nation once deeply divided by apartheid, is now trying to mend its wounds by uniting under the banners of cosmopolitanism and nationalism. South Africa’s vital interest lies in the need to strengthen its national identity whilst recognizing its role in contributing to the cosmopolitan ideal of Ubuntu, specifically on the African continent. Ubuntu is a traditional isiZulu phrase which translates to “I am because you are” (5) and is centered on fostering collective growth in a community....
Nationalist Identity politics in Russia Introduction: In this report, Russian nationalist identity politics will be examined through the use of findings and discussion. Below a list of results from extensive research will be listed, then followed by a brief discussion on how Putin uses Russian Nationalism to assert dominance and control over the west. Firstly though, a brief overview. Relations between the west and Russia are at their worst since the Cold war, yet Nationalism is on the rise with...
Certain general suppositions about human instinct underlie patriot guessing, to be specific, that people are naturally social-social animals, either conceived or acknowledged into specific social networks that both shape them and are supported by them, in and through which they discover a lot of their importance and noteworthiness, and to which they definitely owe certain obligations and loyalties. These educate yet don’t characterize nationalism, for they may apply to any social gathering. At the point when, how and why any...
The 20th century marked turning points for many nations in terms of governance and governmental structure. Two nations that were no exception include Russia and Mexico. Both of these nations went through a revolution; Mexico in 1910 and Russia in 1917, which led to vast changes in their governments. Although the Mexican revolution resulted in a constitution and and outline for democratic principles, the nation quickly became a one party state. After the 1917 revolution in Russia, the Soviet Union...
01 / 09
Fair Use Policy
EduBirdie considers academic integrity to be the essential part of the learning process and does not support any violation of the academic standards. Should you have any questions regarding our Fair Use Policy or become aware of any violations, please do not hesitate to contact us via firstname.lastname@example.org.
We are here 24/7 to write your paper in as fast as 3 hours.